Great lashes should not come at the cost of animal welfare. We tested 15 vegan mascaras over 6 weeks, evaluating volume, length, smudge-resistance, and wear time. These 6 delivered dramatic results without a single animal-derived ingredient.
From tubing formulas that never smudge to fiber-lash technology that adds instant length, there is a vegan mascara for every lash goal and budget.
Pros
Cons
The best vegan mascara we tested. The tubing formula wraps each lash in tiny tubes that extend length dramatically. What sets it apart: zero smudging, ever. Even after a full day and gym session, it looked fresh. Removal is surprisingly gentle — just warm water and the tubes slide right off.
Pros
Cons
If volume is your priority, this delivers. The hourglass-shaped brush catches every lash — even the tiny corner ones — and builds dramatic thickness without clumping. Our testers with sparse lashes saw the biggest difference. Just let it dry fully before blinking to avoid transfer.
Pros
Cons
The best vegan mascara under $10. The curved brush genuinely lifts lashes — several testers skipped their eyelash curler. While it is not as dramatic as Tarte or Too Faced, it delivers clean, defined, fluttery lashes at a price that lets you stock up.
Pros
Cons
Pacifica created a mascara that actually cares for your lashes. The vitamin B and coconut oil infusion meant our testers noticed less lash fallout after 4 weeks of use. The smaller wand gives precise application but takes more strokes for full coverage. Ideal if you want natural, healthy-looking lashes.
Pros
Cons
Milani brings fiber-lash technology to the drugstore aisle. The tiny fibers attach to your natural lashes, creating noticeable length that looks surprisingly natural. Our testers loved how lightweight it felt — like wearing nothing at all. Just apply carefully; the fibers need a quick comb-through to avoid spider lashes.
Pros
Cons
For sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, this is the safest bet. Hypoallergenic and packed with organic ingredients, it caused zero irritation in our sensitive-eye testers. The trade-off is subtlety — you get defined, dark lashes but not dramatic volume. Perfect for everyday, no-makeup makeup looks.
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. We earn a commission when you purchase through our links — at no extra cost to you.
Vegan mascaras contain no animal-derived ingredients like beeswax, lanolin, or carmine. They use plant-based waxes such as carnauba or candelilla wax, and mineral or synthetic pigments for color.
Yes. Many vegan mascaras now outperform conventional formulas. Plant-based waxes can be just as effective at holding curl and adding volume. The key is finding the right brush and formula for your lash type.
Let each coat dry fully before applying the next. Set your under-eye area with powder before applying mascara. For extra insurance, use a tubing formula like Tarte Tartelette — tubing mascaras physically wrap lashes and only come off with warm water.
Founder of Beautiful Vegan
Testing cruelty-free skincare since 2009. Committed to helping you find beauty products that work for your skin and the planet.
More from CaseyJoin 5,000+ readers getting weekly cruelty-free product picks and ingredient guides.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.